HomeEntertainmentMariah Carey Sued Again Over ‘All I Want for Christmas is You’ — By The Same Guy
Mariah Carey Sued Again Over ‘All I Want for Christmas is You’ — By The Same Guy
1 November 2023
In the realm of holiday music, there are a few timeless classics that always resurface as soon as the calendar flips to December. Mariah Carey’s “All I Want for Christmas is You” undoubtedly stands as one of those timeless gems. However, it seems that the joyous jingle bells accompanying the song’s release are often met with legal jingles, as Mariah Carey has once again found herself embroiled in a lawsuit over her iconic Christmas hit. What makes this case particularly interesting is that it’s not the first time the same individual has taken legal action against the pop diva.
The Festive Fiasco: A Brief Recap
For those who have lost track of the legal wrangling surrounding “All I Want for Christmas is You,” here’s a quick refresher. Mariah Carey’s ubiquitous holiday anthem was released back in 1994 and has since become an essential part of the Christmas music canon. In 2017, the song’s co-writer, Walter Afanasieff, sued Carey for $1 million in unpaid royalties and credit disputes. Afanasieff claimed that he co-wrote the song’s music and deserved his fair share of the financial pie.
Now, in a surprising turn of events, Walter Afanasieff is back in court, but this time, he’s not alone. He is once again suing Mariah Carey, but this time for alleged defamation, as well as copyright infringement and other damages related to the use of “All I Want for Christmas is You.”
The Defamation Claim
The most intriguing aspect of this new lawsuit is Afanasieff’s defamation claim. He asserts that Mariah Carey made false and damaging statements about him during her promotional campaign for her Christmas special. According to Afanasieff, Carey painted him as a villain, claiming that he had no part in the creation of the song, and that her co-writing was the sole driving force behind its success. Afanasieff argues that these remarks have had a significant negative impact on his reputation and career.
Copyright Infringement and Other Damages
In addition to the defamation claim, Afanasieff is also pursuing a copyright infringement case against Carey. He argues that she used parts of the song, which he co-wrote, in her Christmas special without proper permission or compensation. Afanasieff claims that this unauthorized use has led to financial losses and is seeking damages accordingly.
The ongoing lawsuit alleges various other damages, including emotional distress and loss of income, claiming that the negative statements made by Mariah Carey have hindered his ability to find work in the industry.
The Complexities of Co-Writing
This case highlights the complexities of co-writing in the music industry. The process of songwriting often involves multiple individuals contributing various elements, such as lyrics, melodies, and arrangements. Determining who deserves what share of the credit and royalties can be a challenging task, leading to legal disputes like the ones between Mariah Carey and Walter Afanasieff.
The Future of ‘All I Want for Christmas is You’
As this legal battle continues, the fate of one of the most beloved holiday songs in the world hangs in the balance. Fans of Mariah Carey’s Christmas classic can only hope that a resolution is reached that allows the song to keep spreading joy during the holiday season.
The story of Mariah Carey’s legal battle over “All I Want for Christmas is You” takes another twist as Walter Afanasieff sues the pop icon once again, this time on defamation and copyright infringement grounds. While the legal system works to untangle the web of co-writing and artistic credit, it’s essential to remember the joy that this song brings to countless people each holiday season. Whatever the outcome, the enduring appeal of the song itself is likely to remain unchanged, a cherished part of the festive season for many years to come.